“The Great Replacement” in Europe and in America

All of us are limited in our time and concentration, and over the last couple of weeks I’ve been heavily focused on the Middle East tinderbox and other military conflicts. So although I’d heard something about the large public protests in Paris and other French urban centers, I hadn’t paid much attention to them, nor realized how serious they had become.
But Tucker Carlson had, and in one of his shows late last week, he spent more than 150 minutes using those high-profile events as a starting point for a discussion of broader issues.
Watch the full video HERE
Apparently there was quite a lot of violent looting and arson taking place, and early in his podcast he provided a montage of those scenes. These suggested that some of the disturbances were at least on a par with what had happened in our own country during the Black Lives Matter protests of a few years ago.
There’s also a widely circulated clip in which a woman confronted the looters of a Paris shop. She denounced them for severely damaging the cause of the anti-government protests, which she herself had strongly supported.
Watch the full video HERE
Across the Internet, many conservatives and right-wingers have eagerly seized upon these events, claiming that they demonstrated the dreadful consequences of French immigration policies over the last couple of generations, which have left it with a substantial population of urban Muslims. Indeed, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu almost gleefully declared that Hamas was currently on the streets of the French capital just as he had previously warned French President Emmanuel Macron.
Carlson took a much more restrained view, but he did note that the video evidence suggested that a very substantial fraction of the looters and rioters were non-white, hardly conforming to the mental image that most of us still possess of traditional French society. So whether or not they were born in France, they clearly came from an immigrant background. Over the last couple of generations, large waves of such immigrants, mostly from Francophone North or Sub-Saharan Africa had drastically reshaped the demographics of French society.
For many years, critics on the right have begun calling this sweeping ethnic transformation of France and most other European countries “the Great Replacement.” Although our mainstream media has regularly denounced this notion as “a far-right conspiracy theory,” it seems factually correct at least to some extent.
One very important point made by Carlson is that simply determining the ethnic and racial composition of France or its major urban centers is actually quite difficult. The overwhelming bulk of these French demographic changes took place over the last half-century, and he mentioned that by a strange coincidence a law had been passed in 1978 prohibiting the government from collecting any such racial or ethnic statistics. The supposed ideological basis for such legally enforced blindness was that that all French citizens were one and the same, and distinguishing between their backgrounds would violate the colorblind principles established by the French Revolution. This sweeping prohibition even carried over to non-citizens as well.
So no one can say with any great confidence how many of the people living in France today can trace their ancestry back to Napoleonic times, or instead illegally arrived yesterday from Morocco or Burkina Faso. Many people have believed that a government can better deal with its various social problems if it possessed a good statistical understanding of its own society, but French lawmakers apparently disagree.
However, France has been something of an ideological outlier on those matters, and most of its fellow members of the European Union do collect such statistics, so these might provide at least some indications of what the ones for France would be. These figures were usefully excerpted in a short clip from Carlson’s show that has quickly accumulated more than 2,000 comments, and the figures he quoted were certainly quite dramatic:
- Brussels, Belgium was 95% European in 1955 and is now 21% European.
- London, England was 97% English in 1955 and is today 36%.
- Amsterdam was 98% and is now 40%.
- Berlin was 98% and is now 57%.
- Vienna was 95% and is now 51%.
- Stockholm was 97% and is now 65%.
Based upon these demographic trends, Carlson argued that within our own lifetimes there will not be a single remaining white majority nation in the world except for Russia. He wondered whether this exception might somehow be related to the massive hatred expressed against that latter country by most Western elites.
These ongoing demographic changes have been absolutely remarkable in their scale and their speed, sweeping across most European countries and the rest of the white world over just the last couple of generations, population shifts almost unprecedented in world history.
Indeed, more than fifteen years ago I had published a lengthy article in The American Conservative making very similar observations about the racial transformation taking place in our own country:
Last June the U.S. Census disclosed that non-white births in America were on the verge of surpassing the white total and might do so as early as the end of this year. Such an event marks an unprecedented racial watershed in American history. Over the last few years, various demographic projections from that same agency and independent analysts have provided somewhat fluctuating estimates of the date—perhaps 2042 or 2037 or 2050—at which white Americans will become a minority. This represents a remarkable, almost unimaginable, demographic change from our country of the early 1960s, when whites accounted for over 85 percent of the population and seemed likely to remain at that level indefinitely.
Many years of heavy foreign immigration have been the crucial element driving this transformation, but even if all immigration—legal and illegal—were halted tomorrow and the border completely sealed, these demographic trends would continue, although at a much slower pace. Today, the median age of American whites is over 40, putting most of them past their prime child-bearing years. Meanwhile, America’s largest minority group, the rapidly growing population of Hispanics, has a median age in the mid-20s, near the peak of family formation and growth, while both Asians and blacks are also considerably younger than whites. In fact, since 1995 births rather than immigration have been the largest factor behind the near doubling of America’s Hispanic population…
These national changes in racial distribution have been quite uneven and geographically skewed, with some parts of the country leading and others lagging. For example, during the 1970s when I was a teenager growing up in the Los Angeles area, that city and the surrounding sprawl of Southern California constituted America’s whitest region, about the only large urban agglomeration whose racial character approximated that of the country as a whole—around 85 percent white—and my own San Fernando Valley area in particular exemplified the popular image of suburban picket fences and lighthearted “Leave It to Beaver” family comedies. Yet during the two decades that followed, Southern California underwent an enormous immigration-driven demographic transformation, creating a new Los Angeles which was almost 80 percent non-white and a surrounding region in which whites no longer held even a mere plurality.
This sweeping racial shift, involving the movement or displacement of over ten million people, might easily rank as the largest in the peacetime history of the world and is probably matched by just a handful of the greatest population changes brought about by war. The racial transformation in America’s national population may be without precedent in human history.
- Immigration, Republicans, and the End of White America
Ron Unz • The American Conservative • September 19, 2011 • 12,200 Words
The Economic Motive for Heavy Immigration
But although Carlson and I agree on the existence of this phenomenon, I would probably disagree with him on some important points.
Like most conservatives who have promoted “the Great Replacement Theory,” he speculated that there might be a conscious intent to target white European countries for replacement with non-whites.
While this is certainly possible, I personally think it much more likely that this outcome is the emergent result of a vector-sum combination of different economic, ideological, and political forces.
Probably the most important is the first of these. Business groups have always had a very strong economic incentive to import additional willing workers in order to drive down wages, and in recent decades they have gained unprecedented influence over both American political parties.
Therefore, it may be more than merely coincidental that during that same period, the political mainstreams of both those parties have begun embracing an open borders doctrine though doing so for entirely different ideological reasons. In that same article, I noted how this had become glaringly obvious during the otherwise bitter 2004 presidential campaign:
The political reality is that both major parties are enormously dependent upon the business interests that greatly benefit from the current system and are also dominated by disparate ideologies—libertarian open-borders and multicultural open-borders—whose positions tend to coincide on this issue.
As an extreme example of the bizarre ideological views of our current political elites, consider a less-publicized element of the immigration reform plan that President George W. Bush trumpeted during his 2004 reelection campaign. This provision would have allowed any foreigner anywhere in the world to legally immigrate to America if he accepted a minimum-wage job that no American were willing to fill, an utterly insane proposal which would have effectively transformed America’s minimum wage into its maximum wage. Naturally his opponent, Sen. John Kerry, saw absolutely nothing wrong with this idea, though he did criticize various other aspects of Bush’s immigration plan as being somewhat mean-spirited.
Progressives had always opposed this, but over time neoliberal sentiments have been so deeply embedded within their younger generations that anyone who remained in opposition was almost considered a heretic.
In a later article, I cited an obvious example of how this generational shift manifested itself in the 2016 presidential campaign:
Earlier this year, Democratic presidential candidate Bernie Sanders, an elderly individual with unabashed socialistic views, was interviewed by Vox‘s Ezra Klein, and explained that “of course” heavy foreign immigration—let alone “open borders”—represented the economic dream of extreme free market libertarians such as the Koch brothers, since that policy would obviously drive down the wages of workers and greatly advantage Capital at the expense of Labor. These notions scandalized his neoliberal interlocutor, and the following day another Vox colleague joined in the attack, harshly denouncing the candidate’s views as “ugly” and “wrongheaded,” while instead pointing to the editorial page of the Wall Street Journal as the proper font of progressive economic doctrine. Faced with such sharp attacks by young and influential Democratic pundits less than half his age, Sanders soon retreated from his simple statement of fact, and henceforth avoided raising the immigration issue during the remainder of his campaign.
Thus, among progressives, this multiculturalist advocacy of open borders had largely replaced the worker concerns of past generations.
Carlson noted that unions had been a leading element of the political coalition that enacted our own 1924 Immigration Act, but the complete collapse of union power during the last couple of generations had now removed most of that political pressure.
This was entirely correct, and in that earlier 2011 article I had emphasized that the special characteristics of those unions that still remain somewhat powerful had greatly magnified that effect:
Meanwhile, many other powerful lobbies within our political system derive important real or perceived benefits from endless population growth. The massive inflow of often impoverished and desperate immigrants tends to weaken unions and drive down working-class wages, thereby increasing corporate profits, a slice of which is then rebated back to the campaign accounts of the elected officials who maintain such policies…
After all, the concept that a huge influx of eager workers would tend to benefit Capital at the expense of Labor is hardly astonishing, nor does it require years of academic research into the intricacies of economic theory.
Consider, for example, the case of self-educated union activist Cesar Chavez, a liberal icon of the 1960s who today ranks as the top Latino figure in America’s progressive pantheon. During nearly his entire career, Chavez stood as a vigorous opponent of immigration, especially of the undocumented variety, repeatedly denouncing the failure of the government to enforce its immigration laws due to the pervasive influence of the business lobby and even occasionally organizing vigilante patrols at the Mexican border. Indeed, the Minutemen border activists of a few years back were merely following in Chavez’s footsteps and would have had every historical right to have named their organization the “Cesar Chavez Brigade.” I think a good case can be made that during his own era Chavez ranked as America’s foremost anti-immigration activist.
But today’s union leaders have grown almost completely silent on the obvious impact that large increases in the supply of labor have on the economic well-being of ordinary workers. A crucial explanation is that for reasons of citizenship and language, the overwhelming majority of immigrants are employed in the private sector, particularly the small-scale non-unionized private sector. Meanwhile, population growth tends to increase the need for teachers, police officers, firefighters, and other government employees, thereby benefiting the powerful public-sector unions that today completely dominate the labor movement.
- Immigration, Republicans, and the End of White America
The Politics of Rich and Poor
Ron Unz • The American Conservative • September 19, 2011 • 12,200 Words
Unlike in America, the private sector unions in most European countries still remain quite powerful, but the public sector unions and other organizations paid by the government to provide services also have enormous clout, and their contrasting interests regarding immigration may weaken any possibility that the labor movement as a whole might balance the business interests arrayed on the other side.
Furthermore, other factors also come into play.
Since the end of World War II and especially over the last couple of generations, a central tenet of the dominant Western ideology has been the complete impermissibility of distinguishing between individuals based upon their race or ethnicity. So any argument against allowing the entry of large numbers of foreigners of a different background into a country is almost considered illegitimate on its face.
The birth rates in European countries are now well below replacement level, and the same has also been true in our own. So political leaders have argued that high levels of continuing immigration are necessary to maintain national populations, and if all people are considered alike and interchangeable, opposing this sort of policy becomes ideologically suspect.
Thus, although there may be no groups in Europe, America, or the rest of the Western world that are actually pro-replacement, there are very powerful political forces that are strongly anti-anti-replacement.
One likely reason for the sharp decline in American birth rates has been that over the last half-century a smaller and smaller share of the financial benefits of productivity growth has been going to ordinary workers. This may be easily seen in this chart from a dozen years ago, and since then those same unfortunate trends have generally continued.
Raising additional children under such trying circumstances is hardly easy, and the younger generation of Americans has often found it quite difficult to even afford marriage, let alone hoping to purchase a home.
A substantial portion of the relative economic decline that is keeping birthrates depressed has probably been caused by high rates of past immigration. But the solution proposed by many political leaders is simply more immigration, a policy that is obviously far more agreeable to them than challenging the powerful business interests who benefit from the current distribution of income.
With mixed success, some countries around the world have made efforts to raise the birthrates of their own population. But among many Westerners, such policies have been deeply tainted by their ideological association with rightwing governments of the present and the past. For example, Nazi Germany stands as the most obvious case of a country that very successfully raised its birthrates during the half-dozen years prior to the outbreak of war.
So I think the combination of the powerful interests that economically benefit from high immigration rates and these other political pressures and ideological constraints may together reasonably explain the striking demographic trajectories that Carlson reported.
Violent Unrest in France and the BLM Protests in America
In his show, Carlson also argued that decades of heavy immigration from a variety of different non-European regions had completely undermined the racial and ethnic cohesion of most European countries and their larger cities.
The resulting social fragmentation greatly reduced their stability, and this might have been a crucial factor behind the current French riots.
It seemed quite possible that Paris and other major French cities were now very substantially non-European, at least in their more youthful age cohorts. This might help explain how political protests that had begun as entirely peaceful ones had quickly devolved into waves of violent rioting, arson, and looting.
Carlson’s notions went double or triple for his guest on the show, whose interview filled more than half the time. Jason Killmeyer had served as ICE chief of staff until leaving his position earlier this year after the shakeup of that department following the highly controversial killings of two American citizens in Minneapolis.
Killmeyer seemed absolutely convinced that the scenes of turmoil from Paris would soon be coming to American cities as well unless massive efforts were immediately made to deport the vast numbers of non-white aliens whose presence here threatened to destroy our society.
Given that America’s very survival was at stake, Killmeyer felt that the strongest possible methods must be used. He believed that the Trump Administration needed to quickly create a governmental deportation force of 250,000 American citizen-volunteers, who would go door-to-door across all of our cities, rousting out the many millions of immigrant-invaders and packing them off home.
Carlson seemed rather skeptical of this dramatic proposal. He noted that the Democrats were likely to control Congress after the mid-terms, and they might react badly if Trump suddenly established what amounted to a right-wing national militia a quarter-million strong, and then sent them on neighborhood sweeps in all American cities. But Killmeyer was adamant, saying that with our national survival at stake, no half-measures would do.
He seemed absolutely sincere in his beliefs, and he mentioned that in the years after the 9/11 Attacks he’d grown up delivering pizzas and listening to Glenn Beck and Mark Levin as they described the dire threat that America faced from the growth of Shariah law. When I checked, I discovered that he’d majored in psychology in college and considered himself a great expert on foreign terrorism, neither of which greatly surprised me.
Although this analysis of the events unfolding in France might be correct, the relationship between the non-white immigrant population of a city and its tendency towards violent urban unrest seems far from obvious to me.
The scenes of Paris violence shown by Carlson strongly brought to mind our own Black Lives Matters protests of 2020. Just as in France, peaceful protests had also soon shifted into violent rioting and looting in many urban centers.
But although neither our mainstream nor our conservative media ever reported it, BLM violence actually followed a rather surprising urban pattern, exactly contrary to what most people probably assumed, both then and now. I discussed this in a 2020 article.
The last few weeks have seen the greatest wave of American urban unrest in two generations. Massive protests, riots, and looting have swept across dozens of our major cities, accompanied by an enormous amount of political vandalism, often targeting monuments to our country’s former presidents and other historical figures…
Over the last few decades, America’s urban centers have become overwhelmingly non-white and heavily immigrant, with residents of European ancestry these days reduced to less than 35% of the total. But within this national average, some cities are still largely white, and these have demonstrated an intriguing pattern.
Two of the American cities that have experienced the longest and most sustained urban chaos and anti-government disorder over the last couple of months have been Portland, Oregon and Seattle, Washington, and these are two of our cities that have remained the most overwhelmingly white, each in the range of 65-70%. The flashpoint of America’s racial convulsion was Minneapolis, and its city government has now voted to “defund” the local police department while nearly a quarter of its officers have already announced their plans to quit. Minneapolis is another major demographic outlier, still being 60% white.
Meanwhile, whites had already become a minority decades ago in my own state of California, and this shift has been especially strong in the larger cities, with white Europeans probably down to little more than 20% in Los Angeles and San Jose, while remaining perhaps 35% in San Diego and San Francisco. During my younger years, LA had been America’s most overwhelmingly white large city, and over the last half century it had also developed a reputation for especially deadly racial rioting, becoming notorious for the Watts Riots of 1965 and the Rodney King Riots of 1992. But the disorders this time were very mild by comparison, and almost entirely limited to Westside looting by the local black population, now reduced to less than 10% of the total. Unrest in other California cities has been even more minimal in recent weeks, nothing at all like what has wracked so many other American urban centers.
I noticed this same pattern even closer to home when I compared Palo Alto, quite affluent and over 90% white and Asian, with neighboring East Palo Alto, heavily immigrant and working-class, over 90% non-white with few Asians.
For decades my hometown has been extremely liberal but politically rather placid, and this remained the case in June and July, with activism mostly confined to a large (and overwhelmingly white) Black Lives Matter protest march, accompanied by a little minor vandalism. More recently, BLM activists painted a huge visual affirmation of their creed on the street in front of City Hall, and arranged to partially exclude traffic from that block to prevent cars from damaging their design. Most controversially, a portion of their mural honored a militant from the Black Liberation Army, who had murdered a police officer in 1973, afterward breaking out of prison and escaping to Cuba. Local police officers have expressed considerable irritation at seeing this tribute to a convicted cop-killer so close to their own headquarters.
This sort of minor ideological ferment hardly matches the endless rounds of protest and violence in Portland or Seattle, but still exceeded anything taking place in neighboring East Palo Alto, which as far as I can tell has been entirely quiet after a couple of protest marches by local blacks in early June.
- The Political Bankruptcy of American White Nationalism
Ron Unz • The Unz Review • July 27, 2020 • 3,400 Words
The Unspoken Racial Pattern of American Urban Crime
When both our mainstream and our conservative media fail to highlight or even report important racial patterns in American society, these may remain largely unnoticed by the general population, with many individuals even casually assuming something entirely contrary.
I suspect that most conservative activists, Killmeyer certainly included, would be shocked if they were informed that the cities experiencing the worst urban violence and rioting during the BLM upheavals of 2020 were the whitest ones, while the most heavily immigrant and non-white cities were generally among the most tranquil.
Those racial upheavals of 2020 were one-off events that only lasted for a few months. But for decades, American urban crime rates have suffered from a very similar pattern of widespread confusion as I demonstrated in a major statistical analysis that I published more than a dozen years ago.
In conservative political circles, there is often a widespread assumption that immigrant groups and Hispanics in particular have high crime rates. The notorious flaws in our racial arrest statistics have fostered this impression, with many localities often categorizing Hispanic criminals as white. This has led to dark suspicions that government authorities are deliberately concealing the very high criminality of that population.